Saturday 07/02/2016 by johnnyd

SPAC1: NOT JUST WARM UP ANYMORE

I love SPAC.

The lawn, the lot. The park, the palace. The people. It’s a homecoming, almost as regular on the 3.0 schedule as Dick’s. It’s a thing. The only time we don’t get SPAC is when there’s a festival, and that is wholly forgivable.


It wasn’t always that way. This is a 3.0 tour development. Prior to this run, Phish had played here 17 times -- 16 headliners and an opener for Santana -- but only thrice in 1.0. Our more-or-less annual independence jaunt to ‘Toga is a new staple on the calendar, relatively speaking. The toney town might not have worked for us in the mid-to-late ‘90s. Or, more likely, the stop did not make sense if we were annually festivaling in the region. But for now, this is a town with not only a pool and a pond, but also springs, and a spa. And in recent years, our traveling contingent has been warmly welcomed to whichever of the above we can afford.

SPAC has had its share of highlights over the years. The massive “DWD” -> “Free” in ‘95 and the whole damn 2004 run stand out, but in recent years, while there have been some memorable moments every stand, most would sooner associate “solid run, awesome fun” than “holy cow the SPAC xxx” with the events of the past five out of seven years. But enough backstory -- you can get all that and more in The Phish Companion, 3rd Edition. Let’s talk about now.

I want to describe the first set as hot garbage. But I can’t. The sound was more of a tepid, muddled, pukey stew from our spot in the balcony. A flaccid “Stealing Time From the Faulty Plan” opener took us collectively from midnight to six, and perfunctory runs through a bunch of staples fought to keep the crowd engaged. The “Cities,” “David Bowie,” “Free” sequence looks like it should move the needle on paper, but in reality barely did. I’m pretty sure Fishman was killing it for stretches of “Bowie,” but I can’t confirm -- again, the sound was mush. Felt like I was listening to a boomy 3rd gen ‘99 AUD of the show.

Things crystallized and grooved a little after that, but let’s just stipulate that when “Halfway to the Moon,” “New Song,” “Waiting All Night” is the part of the set that gets things moving, you have issues, and you start to primarily appreciate the environment, your friends, the fact that nobody has stubbed into your spot, etc. For the record, “New Song”, AKA “Let’s Go” is awesome. Sounds like a Bruce Hornsby tune -- maybe something off Spirit Trail.

The new lights are cool as shit. I’m generally much more concerned with and cognizant about what is going in my earholes than my eyeholes at a show, but this was the kind of set where I took notice of whatever else was going on around me. The screens are a bold and very welcome departure from what we’re used to -- subdued and atmospheric, as compared to a bazillion technicolor watts flashing at you.

Golgi Apparatus” started, and it was like a welcome to us all. Some old school, prototypical tension and release. It seemed like the first song of the run -- a departure from the first set to end all first sets. We headed out of the balcony through “Squirming Coil” and I the sound was orders of magnitude better literally every step of the way, including in the bathroom, than where we were in the balcony. We resolved to find our friends on the lawn for the second set.

And that we did, dead center. When “Sand” kicked in there was a palpable relief -- like something might happen here. And it did.

Sometimes it seems like Phish can flip a switch. I’ve caught this phenomenon a good handful of times and often wondered how they can straight from 0 to 11? Is it intentional? Why don’t they do it all the time? I have no idea, but that’s what happened. Game on for SPAC, and game on for summer 2016.

Sand” > “Carini” > “Chalk Dust Torture” is the stuff Phish dreams are made of. Trey stepped up and decided to play assertively. That doesn’t necessarily mean a million notes per second, but rather, masterfully manipulating the Echoplex and effects to bounce sound waves off his bandmates and all of us. The rhythmic echoes deep in “CDT” are a Phish, and a music, that I haven’t heard before. And I love it. But let’s blend some old with the new -- they somehow land near the Camden ‘99 “Chalkdust.” Again, is this intentional? Have they decided to jam on their own jams, or did they just meander over to one of their pantheon soundscapes? I don’t know, I’m not behind the curtain.

The run from “Prince Caspian” through “Sleeping Monkey” looks atrocious in a second set, for those that prejudge such things. But again, I’m here, reviewing from the ground. And we were so deep into gravy territory that I’m pretty sure it was phenomenal. Re-listens will tell. They packed a metric assload of “2001” into six minutes, and then Trey absolutely let rip on “Fire.”

Phish seems once again to be playing a type of music that maybe “they haven’t quite invented yet” and I love the process and the ride, detours along the way, warts and all. Some bands, you want to catch on their first night of a tour or run. They blow out a pent up energy, but don’t have a ton to add after that. Phish is not that band..

I think and hope they dropped it into gear last night. Let’s get this show on the road.

If you liked this blog post, one way you could "like" it is to make a donation to The Mockingbird Foundation, the sponsor of Phish.net. Support music education for children, and you just might change the world.


Comments

, comment by whatstheuse324
whatstheuse324 This was a show with a first set encore, multi-part jams in Carini, Camden 99 Chalkdust Jr., a Camden 99 Chalkdust reprise on the marimba luna, and a four song encore before the encore. It was a fun show to be at. There was a huge hail storm and tornado warnings less than two hours before the start of the show, everything worked out though. Nothing was run of the mill about this one.
, comment by whatstheuse324
whatstheuse324 Also, nice job JohnnyD. I liked your line about them playing music that they haven't quite invented yet.
, comment by Rick_like_an_Antelope
Rick_like_an_Antelope Nice review @johnnyd ! Wish I was there. See you in CA+CO, Phish.
, comment by Tanner22
Tanner22 Bathtub?
, comment by andrewrose
andrewrose Feel like during the marimba lumina sequence at the end of Chalk Dust Trey was quoting from an 80s pop song I can't quite place. Anyway, that jam was incredible. Had an amazing time.. My thoughts here!
, comment by KingMob
KingMob Don't even worry about it! Nothing to see here, move along now. @Tanner22 said:
Bathtub?
, comment by andrewrose
andrewrose Trey quotes Depeche Mode 'I Just Can't Get Enough' during the marimba lumina jam segment..
, comment by RobesPierre
RobesPierre are you reviewing your horrible balcony seat or the music?
, comment by DeliStyle
DeliStyle I'll add more later. Let me say "let's go" has potential the jamming in this is great but is currently cut short they need to experiment with this more.
, comment by CapnJenks
CapnJenks Agree with RobesPierre. Sorry for your seats. You clearly were at a different show. BS review imho
, comment by FACTSAREUSELESS
FACTSAREUSELESS love the writing style, and the take. It's too bad the sound crapped on you in the first set. I feel your pain. I've been in SPAC when the sound is exquisite and also when it's lousy. It's feast or famine in that joint.

Happy they were able to go to 11.
, comment by FACTSAREUSELESS
FACTSAREUSELESS @andrewrose said:
Feel like during the marimba lumina sequence at the end of Chalk Dust Trey was quoting from an 80s pop song I can't quite place. Anyway, that jam was incredible. Had an amazing time.. My thoughts here!
Just read your write-up. Great take! The encore call was funny stuff.
, comment by Wulfy
Wulfy This is a terrible review lol
, comment by strikly_commerical
strikly_commerical Oh sure man - stub yourself down to the lawn, why don't ya
, comment by plICCULUS
plICCULUS @strikly_commerical said:
Oh sure man - stub yourself down to the lawn, why don't ya
LOL :)
, comment by Dianna_2Ns
Dianna_2Ns Also loved "Let's Go" & think that song definitely has potential to be a jam vehicle. Spot on about the 7/10/99 CDT, too.
, comment by piper24
piper24 Its so refreshing to finally see some honest reviews that aren't full of fluff or excuses. And it's hilarious that most people can't take it. These guys aren't musical gods. They're gonna blow it sometimes. And that's ok. You just keep listening. most of you guys wouldn't know a good show if it slapped you in the face but that's a subject for another time. :)
, comment by johnnyd
johnnyd Thanks to everyone who read the review.

Replies to a couple of comments:

@RobesPierre
"are you reviewing your horrible balcony seat or the music?"

The music, as heard through my (fine) balcony seat, that was unfortunately and unexcusably located outside the soundscape of the main speakers. When we have a review from the couch we tend to get eaten alive because, "hey, you had to be there, maaan!" Turns out the venue sound system is part of that equation. I wrote about what I heard - which was so muddled that I couldn't even tell that the Birds was the Birds, and was slow to recognize songs that I've heard hundreds of time. There were phasing or delay issues on top of the entire absence of any midrange signal at all. It sounded like they weren't even in rhythm with each other. Felt committed to spend the first set there because that was my actual concert experience, but so glad so stub myself down to the lawn. Sound, space, and yes, even the view, were fantastic for the subsequent 5 sets.

@Tanner22
"Bathtub?"

I didn't forget to mention the Gin/Coil. I left them out because I couldn't think of anything interesting or descriptive to say about them. You can look at the setlist and see that they are there. The Gin is substantially similar to other late first set placements (Magna excepted of course). So, yes - as @KingMob replied, "Nothing to see here," relatively speaking. Gin was Gin.

Now that the run is in the books, my overall take is way less hot than many people who think the sky is falling. We had an incredible weekend, and enjoyed every moment - including that first set - where I was taking notes for this review and my wife and I were absolutely cracking each other up with jokes and comments on the epic sound fail.

Quick version from the forum:
Overall I think the shows were better than some of the harshest reviews. I don't think we're anywhere near the sky-is-falling scenario that is being painted in some spots. There were some really nice highlights throughout; isolated flubs barely make my radar; and I've always been one to say "the band should play whatever the f*** they want." So I will gladly accept the Joy/Show of Life dick kick and am slowly getting over the blueballs from that show ending. I was so ready to keep on going. Our spot and all our show neighbor's were A+. We were calling for a Piper Ghost Tweezer Slave second encore, then a first tube third encore to wrap things up. Ended up around a campfire through dawn, after a flat out silly stop through a hotel en route back to our spot.

Moral of the story is that even a weekend of "average" Phish is pretty stellar. And their "average" is not exactly a low bar. Can't wait for Hartford and 'Cuse!
For 2.0/3.0, SPAC pav/balcony is now batting an extremely weak 1/4 in terms of concert experience (sound, crowd, atmosphere), having squeaked out a broken bat single on 7/7/2012.
Lawn is batting over .900 for the remaining dozen or so shows I've seen there.
, comment by johnnyd
johnnyd @whatstheuse324 said:
Also, nice job JohnnyD. I liked your line about them playing music that they haven't quite invented yet.
Thanks!

I am pretty sure this is a Trey quote, or at least a close paraphrase, that he used in retrospect to describe fall of 1996 and leading through spring 1997.
, comment by Piper72
Piper72 Great review, Johnny. Great words, and what you do with them. Kinda like what my favorite band does with notes and stuff. :)
, comment by fluff_hen
fluff_hen Right on @johnnyD, thanks for the recap. I had that experience at Deer Creek- sound so muddled in the pav I couldn't hear the show, and #lawn'd it too late. For SPAC 1 had traded pavs for lawns to be with families, and I was really kicking myself during the weather. But Phish tweeted the storms were over, and they control the weather, after all... turned out to be a gorgeous night on the lawn, with sound and sightlines were just fine. I really don't get what people complain about with this venue - it was simply gorgeous. Friday night show was so high energy, felt like the band simply didn't want to get off the stage.
You must be logged in to post a comment.


Phish.net

Phish.net is a non-commercial project run by Phish fans and for Phish fans under the auspices of the all-volunteer, non-profit Mockingbird Foundation.

This project serves to compile, preserve, and protect encyclopedic information about Phish and their music.

Credits | Terms Of Use | Legal | DMCA

© 1990-2024  The Mockingbird Foundation, Inc. | Hosted by Linode